Monday, March 23, 2009

Marching to the Civil War: Drummer Boy

Drummer Boy:
Marching to the Beat of the Civil War
Ann Turner
illustrated by Mark Hes
s

My Rating: 2 out of 5

Genre: Historical Fiction/Primary

Drummer Boy, is a story of a thirteen-year-old boy who is inspired, after the visit of President Abraham Lincoln to his town and listening to him speak, to join the military as a drummer boy. Even though he was two years too young, he was sent to training camp. Soon, he was alongside soldiers fighting in the Civil War and we follow him and his stories of battle.

Drummer Boy is, a picture book which introduces the Civil War to students. While students may enjoy the story the book tells, I think the concepts introduced are too complex for the intended audience, first and second grade students. The character development is jarring, the boy is excited and proud throughout the book, and suddenly on the last page he is a bitter Civil War Soldier. There is a mention of the boy's distaste for slavery, but it seems forced, and even the picture which accompanies the text is dark and muddled in contrast with the rest of the stories brightly detailed illustrations. Overall, the boy is very two-dimensional and is not developed very well.

Keeker and the Sugar Shack


Keeker and the Sugar Shack

Hadley Higginson
illustrated by Maja Anderson

Genre: Realistic Fiction/Primary

My Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Keeker and the Sugar Shack is book two in the Sneaky Pony Series by Hadley Higginson. The main character is spunky little Catherine Corey Keegan Dana - but everyone just calls her Keeker. Keeker is almost ten, and she owns a pony named Plum, who is almost nine. In this book, Keeker learns and old woman has actually moved into the old Crab Apple Hill Farm. Keeker just can't imagine why an old lady would want to move into the old, dilapidated building and feels she has to investigate. Keeker eventually decides the new neighbor must be a witch. Keeker winds up embarrassing herself in the process of her spying, and ultimately learns not to judge a book by its cover.

The Sneaky Pony series is ideal for first through third graders. The series is skewed towards girls, but the adventures are so comical that boys can enjoy them as well - they probably just wouldn't be seen reading them independently! Like the Junie B. Jones series, the Sneaky Pony series are great beginning chapter books, and will encourage reading for students who are growing out of picture books. There is nothing exceptional about these books, but young girls will love to read about Keeker and her silly adventures.

Poe Park


Poe Park
Agnes Martinez


My Rating: 3 out of 5

Genre: Realistic Fiction/Secondary

Martinez's novel, Poe Park, takes place in the Bronx, New York and is narrated by eleven-year-old Enoch. Although Enoch is surrounded by drugs and crime, he could not be happier with life: he has just finished fifth grade and is off to middle school, he is about to celebrate his eleventh birthday, and is planning how he and his best friend, Spencer, are going to spend their summer. Just as their summer is getting started, Spencer is shot and killed. Enoch spends the rest of his summer trying to cope with the pain and anger associated with the loss of his best friend. Compounding his anger and confusion is the realization his best friend was involved in drug running and his older half brother is coming from Puerto Rico to live with he and his mom.

The only element I did not care for in this novel was the lack of development in both the secondary characters and the subplots. The introspective narrative style of the story lead to a lot of "telling" by the author as opposed to "showing", and left a lot to be desired. Overall, an accessable piece of Hispanic American literature with which some students may find a connection.

The City of Ember


The City of Ember
Jeanne DuPrau

My Rating: 5 out of 5

Genre: Science Fiction/Secondary

DuPrau's The City of Ember is post-apocalyptic story about the man-made, self-contained city named Ember. Ember was built 240 years ago by "builders," and its current residents view the city as "the only light in a dark world." Ember's supplies come from large store rooms and a few greenhouses, and they are running low. Its electrical system, providing the only light in the city, comes from an ancient hydro-powered generator below the city in the underground Pipeworks and it is worsening; the city is suffering from blackouts that begin to occur more frequently and for longer periods of time. The main characters, Lina and Doon think there has to be some way to escape the dying city. It is not until one day, when Lina comes across a hidden piece of parchment containing some sort of "instructions" that their adventures to find an escape begin.

The City of Ember, is an engrossing read recommended for students at the middle school level. The setting of the story, while dark and bleak in nature, is brilliantly illustrated through DuPrau's keen use of description. The main characters are appealing, and it is easy for anyone to become immediately attached to them. It is my opinion that this is a novel best used for introducing students to the science fiction genre. For students who read nothing but science fiction and post-apacolyptic novels, the premise of this story is nothing new, it is an accessable plot that can be enjoyed by the majority of students. It can be used in the classroom when thinking about utopian societies and the realities of such places. Also, students can be challenged to think about how they would set up their own ordered society if they were called to do so. Overall, a fun and fscinating read that will have students begging to read the sequel, The People of Spark.

Cinderella versus Cinderella Skeleton













Cinderella

Susan Jeffers

My Rating: 5 out of 5

Genre: Fairy Tale


Cinderella
is the classic fairy tale of a lowly servant girl who is magically transformed into a stunning princess through the help of her Fairy God Mother, just in time for the palace ball. Cinderella was originally forbidden to attend the ball by her evil step mother, and had to watch sadly as her evil step sisters got dressed up and left her alone to clean the house. Brought on by Cinderella's tears, her Fairy Godmother appears and magically provides Cinderella with all that she needs to attend the ball, with the warning that she had to return home by the stroke of midnight because the magic spell would break and everything would return to normal. In her haste to return home before midnight, Cinderella loses her glass slipper which the Prince promptly retrieves and uses to find his true love. He finds Cinderella and they marry, living happily ever after.

Cinderella is character whom students can look up to and admire as someone who is true to they are, no matter what the circumstances are. Cinderella treats everyone with kindness and understanding, no matter how mean and nasty they are. The tale is an obvious choice when introducing the genre of fairy tale to elementary age students. I liked this particular retelling because stays true to the original tale and the illustrations are beautiful and bring the story to life making it a perfect version to read aloud to students.

Cinderella Skeleton
Robert D. San Souci
illustrated by David Catrow

My Rating: 5 out of 5

Genre: Fractured Fairy Tale

Cinderella Skeleton is virtually the same classic Cinderella story, only it is told in rhyme and from the point of view of a skeleton! The setting is vastly different in that it takes place in a decrepit graveyard, Boneyard Acres. Cinderella Skeleton faces the same woes as the original Cinderella; a servant girl living with an evil step mother and step sisters whose only wish is to go the ball. However, in this tale, the Fairy Godmother doesn't go to Cinderella Skeleton, Cinderella Skeleton seeks her out - and she isn't a fairy, she's a witch. The events following are the same as the original Cinderella story, except when she flees from the ball, the prince catches her by the foot and pulls her whole foot off, and not just the slipper! Prince Charnel makes the same vow that the original prince makes, and searches everywhere for the skeleton whose ankle would fit the slippered foot. Prince Charnel eventually makes it to Cinderella Skeleton's mausoleum and finds that the foot belongs to her! Prince Charnel and Cinderella Skeleton live happily ever after, and her three step sisters shriveled with envy and shrank to dust.

Cinderella Skeleton sends the same message as the original Cinderella, however, it is slightly hidden behind graveyards and skeletons. I recommend sharing this version with students for several reasons. First, it is a wonderful piece to show children how the same fairy tale can be retold in different ways and still contain the original elements of the traditional tale. This story can be used with older students as a basis for a writing assignment; students can write their own fractured fairy tale after a comparison and contrast activity with this book. The haunting illustrations make this a great read aloud, especially around Halloween! Overall, one of the better alternate versions of Cinderella that will appeal to boys and girls alike.

One-Eye! Two Eyes! Three-Eyes! A Very Grimm Fairy Tale


One-Eye! Two-Eyes! Three-Eyes!
A Very Grimm Fairy Tale

told by Aaron Shepard
illustrated by Gary Clement

My Rating: 5 out of 5

Genre: Fairy Tale

Aaron Shepard's retelling if the original Brothers Grimm fairy tale, One-Eye! Two-Eyes! Three Eyes!, is a fun to read story about a girl named Two-Eyes and her nasty sisters, One-Eye and Three-Eyes. The three sisters live live alone in a cottage in the woods. Two-Eyes has a miserable life living with her sisters, who constantly make fun of her for only having two eyes. Two-Eyes couldn't help but feel despair and loneliness. However, through the help of a mysterious old woman whom Two-Eyes meets in a meadow, a goat, some magical verses and a handsome knight, Two-Eyes learns to accept herself and finds she is not alone as she once believed she was.

One-Eye! Two-Eyes! Three-Eyes! explores the thematic extremes which are frequently present in the fairy tale genre: want and reward, powerlessness and power, and reversal of fortunes. This tale is a great choice for the discussion of fairy tales in the elementary classroom. It makes a nice alternative to the story of Cinderella and a comparison with the Grimm brothers’ version of the same tale would bring up telling differences. The illustrations are comical and quirky which add to the pleasure of reading this tale aloud to students. Shepard does a great job updating this classic fairy tale and makes it relevant for today's students.

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Annie Christmas


Annie Christmas
told by Virginia Hamilton

illustrated by Leo and Diane Dillon

My Rating: 5 out of 5

Genre: African American Folktale

Annie Christmas is an African American Folktale, published in Her Stories: African American Folktales, Fairy Tales and True Tales. Annie Christmas is a familiar figure in the state of Louisiana. She is larger than life, described as being coal black and tree tall, standing seven feet barefoot and weighing 299 pounds - the biggest woman in the state of Louisiana. She is a keel boat operator on the Mississippi and is as mean as they come.

This story begins with Annie and her friends enjoying a girls' night on the river, and ends with the broken heart of Annie Christmas herself. She falls in love with the captain of a paddle boat, and when she asks for a hug - she is rudely rejected. Angry and broken-hearted, Annie curses the captain, goes back out on the river and throws herself overboard.
Annie was never heard or seen again. Consequently, neither was the captain of the paddle boat, but it is said he haunts the Mississippi River. To this day, you can hear him cursing the bad weather on nights full of rain and darkness. As for Annie, it is said that her sons found her body washed up on shore. Her sons boarded the barge with their mother in a coffin and vanished from sight forever. It is said Annie Christmas is still on the Mississippi River. The black barge emerges from the mist, with her twelve sons aboard and Annie is sitting atop her wooden grave, singing a river tune to the thundering sky.

I would recommend this story, along with the book it is published within, for fourth and fifth grade classrooms for the study of folktales and multicultural literature. Virginia Hamilton is a wonderful author, having won many awards for her literary work. The illustrations are beautiful and add so much depth to the stories. Annie Christmas is a wonderful example of an African American folktale, and demonstrates how the same character is seen across cultures. Students can compare and contrast the African American version of Annie Christmas with those of other cultures, the Irish version, for example. Overall, I think this collection would be a wonderful addition to any classroom library.